Halloween is always the time when MM2 inventories get interesting. The flashy new knives grab all the attention, but if you've traded for a while, you know an older Halloween weapon can be worth much more than this year's drop. Here is how I'd compare 10 older collector favorites with all 10 new Halloween 2026 weapons—without confusing trade values with cash prices.
Quick answer
What's worth the most?
Chroma Traveler's Gun tops this historical list at 140,000 Supreme Value. For the new Halloween 2026 weapons, Chroma Emberscythe is the leader at 14,000. My more approachable pick is regular Emberscythe at 1,700—but its materials can cost more on paper than the finished weapon.
Values are community trading estimates, not Robux, USD, guaranteed trade offers, or investment returns. The lists can update at different times.
Top 10 Most Valuable Older MM2 Halloween Weapons (2015–2025)
If I were building a long-term Halloween display, I'd look here before getting carried away by day-one 2026 hype. These are standard tradable weapons, not one-of-a-kind leaderboard trophies. I ranked them using one consistent baseline: Supreme Values.
| # | Weapon | Supreme | MM2V | Why collectors care |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Chroma Traveler's Gun
Halloween 2023 |
140,000 | 140,000 | Iconic rare Chroma; top collector target |
| 2 |
Chroma Vampire's Gun
Halloween 2024 |
24,500 | 25,000 | High-end Halloween Chroma |
| 3 |
Chroma Alienbeam
Halloween 2025 |
24,000 | 23,000 | High-value 2025 set piece |
| 4 |
Chroma Raygun
Halloween 2025 |
13,000 | 13,275 | Strong paired-set appeal |
| 5 |
Traveler's Axe
Halloween 2023 |
7,700 | 7,450 | Recognizable older Ancient |
| 6 |
Traveler's Gun
Halloween 2023 |
5,200 | 5,150 | Classic 2023 box collectible |
| 7 |
Vampire's Gun
Halloween 2024 |
1,900 | 1,875 | Established matching-set option |
| 8 |
Alienbeam
Halloween 2025 |
1,875 | 1,950 | Popular sci-fi Halloween look |
| 9 |
Raygun
Halloween 2025 |
1,850 | 1,925 | Completes the Alien pair |
| 10 |
Darkshot
Halloween 2023 |
1,675 | 1,700 | Older Dark Set collector pick |
My take: Chroma Traveler's Gun is the obvious dream piece, but Traveler's Axe is the kind of recognizable old Ancient I'd still pay attention to. A high value alone doesn't mean an item will keep rising.
All 10 New MM2 Halloween 2026 Weapons — Value Ranking
This year's lineup is fun because you can go all-in on Chromas or keep it simple with the regular Ember pieces. But here's the catch: newer items are still finding their trading range. I would never assume the higher number from one value site is what another trader will accept.
| Rank | Weapon | Supreme | MM2V | Collector note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Chroma Emberscythe
Chroma Ancient |
14,000 | — | Headline collector item · high volatility |
| 2 |
Chroma Emberbow
Chroma Ancient |
8,000 | 7,500 | Rare event variation · high risk |
| 3 |
Chroma Embersickle
Chroma Godly |
2,500 | 3,750 | Huge list spread; double-check trades |
| 4 |
Chroma Mortal
Chroma Godly |
1,900 | 2,050 | Set collector; limited track record |
| 4 |
Chroma Immortal
Chroma Godly |
1,900 | 2,050 | Set collector; limited track record |
| 6 |
Emberscythe
Ancient Knife |
1,700 | 1,900 | My favorite practical collector pick |
| 6 |
Emberbow
Ancient Gun |
1,700 | 1,700 | Battle Pass-linked demand |
| 8 |
Embersickle
Godly Knife |
200 | 250 | Useful crafting material; high supply risk |
| 8 |
Mortal
Godly Knife |
200 | 175 | Budget display / set completion |
| 8 |
Immortal
Godly Gun |
200 | 175 | Budget companion to Mortal |
Ties share rank numbers. MM2V “—” means no reliable independent price found for this comparison, not zero value. MM2Values.com's published update predates the Supreme snapshot, so differences may reflect both market changes and methodology.
What Would I Actually Collect?
If I wanted one iconic old Halloween weapon
Chroma Traveler's Gun. It's at the top of this historical Value ranking, and it has the kind of recognizable look that makes a Halloween collection feel special. Just remember that “rare” doesn't mean “safe from price drops.”
If I wanted the standout 2026 Chroma
Chroma Emberscythe. At 14,000 Supreme Value it leads this year's new lineup, but that makes it a high-stakes trade while the event is still fresh. I'd check recent offers rather than relying on the list alone.
If I wanted a 2026 item without chasing the highest Value
Regular Emberscythe. It feels like the signature craftable item of this event. There's also a simple trade math warning: Embersickle (200) + Emberbow (1,700) = 1,900 in Supreme points, while the result is listed at 1,700. Crafting isn't automatically the cheaper move.
If I just liked the Halloween look
Mortal and Immortal. At 200 Supreme Value each, they're the low-Value end of this year's list. For a casual collection I'd focus on the pair's design, not a promise of future profit.
Quick MM2 Halloween Value FAQ
Which MM2 Halloween weapon has the highest Value?
Among the normal tradable older Halloween weapons in this ranking, Chroma Traveler's Gun leads at 140,000 Supreme Value. Leaderboard trophies are excluded.
What is Chroma Emberscythe worth in 2026?
14,000 on the Supreme snapshot used here (Oct 22, 2026). Always check the newest update before trading.
Are MM2 Values the same as a shop price?
No. Community Value points help players compare trades. LOLGA's product listing price uses money and should be checked separately.
Should I craft or trade for Emberscythe?
Compare both material values with the finished result, the risk of any randomized outcome, and current player offers first. Theoretical points are not guaranteed transaction prices.
Why do Supreme and MM2Values disagree?
They are independently maintained community lists, and their publication dates can differ. That is especially important during a fresh event with fast-changing demand.
Building Your Own Halloween Collection?
You can compare actual item listings at LOLGA MM2 Shop, or jump straight to Emberscythe, Embersickle and Emberbow. Keep one tab open for trading Values and another for the product details; they're different kinds of prices.
Value Sources & Editorial Notes
Baseline: Supreme Chromas, Supreme Ancients, Supreme Godlies (October 22, 2026). Comparison: MM2Values.com (site update shown as October 18, 2026). Event mechanics: Roblox — Murder Mystery 2 and LOLGA's Cauldron guide.
Product-page links are used for all 20 weapons. Image sources were verified individually; the four images not available from LOLGA were taken from matching game-artwork sources and are credited in the image gallery. Some images are hosted externally and need network access.